Gardner Pie Co

Sheri Beltz 5 months ago

I purchased a butterscotch cream pie for $8 and in and an apple crisp pie for $3.50. They were both big pies!

M. LaVora Perry 6 months ago

I've bought several Gardner fruit pies at Heinen's because they are so delicious. But the last couple of times they were noticeably less sweet than normal. So I called Gardner to let them know. I talked to a floor manager. Surprisingly, I received a call back from Bryan Reynolds, the Director of Food Safety and Quality. Not only did he explain what the cause of the problem may have been and assure me that he would have it taken care of, he sent me $25 gift certificate as compensation! That was totally unexpected. It's nice to know that Gardner really appreciates their customers like this. They still have my business as a result.

Janardhan Katta 6 months ago

Small store front but great tasting pies. Pie day was busy with 50 plus people waiting in line at 8am in the morning. Lots of fruit pies, option of no sugar pies and vegetable pies. Very close to highway too.

G a year ago

My local discount market had their pies. My wife, mother-in-law and I polished off their honey crisp apple pie and are working on their blueberry pie. Delicious! And the blueberry pie is PACKED with blueberries, not too sweet and is one of the best we've ever had. Thank you to all of you at the Gardner Pie Company!

Bud McFadden 3 years ago

I’ve enjoyed Gardner pies since I was a child. I remember dad going down to their old location on Van Buren in Barberton to get pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving a couple of times to give mom a little break from baking. She had so many other irons in the fire. Their location in Portage Lakes is very modern, and convenient. My wife and I have shopped there for many years. We are hard pressed to go in without purchasing at least four pies. You can buy them fresh or pre-frozen. The prices are more than reasonable. The staff is very friendly and professional. They really know their pies. I love their Peanut Butter pie. Unfortunately, you must be an early bird to catch that worm, they sell out so fast. The fruit pies are so good. I love the coconut cream pies. They have more than just pies. The chocolate and peanut butter brownies are great too, we bought some today. I could go on, and on, but I won’t. Gardner pies are sold in some of your local restaurants also. They are just that good.